Team Logo. The Chillicothe Paints were a team in the Frontier League. They lost in the league finals six times without winning a championship. They left the league in 2009 to join the collegiate Prospect League. Retrieved from "https://prosportsteams.fandom.com/wiki/Chillicothe_Paints?oldid=12016" Categories: Former FL Teams Teams in Ohio Add category Cancel Save Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.