Team Logo. The Watertown Indians were a team in the New York-Penn League. They were the Short-Season A affiliate of the Cleveland Indians. In 1999 they moved and became the Staten Island Yankees. Retrieved from "https://prosportsteams.fandom.com/wiki/Watertown_Indians?oldid=10464" Categories: Former NYPL Teams Teams in New York Add category Cancel Save Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.